Transparency

Our sources and method

Donghua Fan is a fan site run by Spidermas. It has no ties to the studios or platforms it covers. This page explains where our information comes from, when it was checked and how we rate the series.

Our sources

Dates, episodes and staff

Release dates, episode counts, studios and staff come first from Bangumi (bgm.tv), the reference database for Chinese and Japanese animation. We cross-check them with the platforms' official pages (Tencent Video, Bilibili, iQIYI, Youku) and, for novels, with publishing platforms such as Qidian.

Where to watch in France

Legal offers in France are checked title by title on JustWatch France. Chinese platforms that stream internationally, often missing from JustWatch, are listed separately, with no guarantee of French subtitles.

French editions

Manhua and novels published in France are checked in the catalogue of the Bibliothèque nationale de France, based on legal deposit: publisher, number of volumes and release dates.

Release calendar

Watch orders and the calendar come from each season's Bangumi entry. The weekly grid is built from episode dates, and it is hidden when the check is more than three weeks old.

Images

Posters, covers and portraits are official visuals taken from Bangumi and AniList entries and used for illustration. Their rights belong to the studios, publishers and platforms.

Texts and reviews

Synopses, analyses and reviews are written for the site, based on the works themselves and the sources above. Reviews and ratings reflect Spidermas's opinion.

Latest checks

Catalogues and schedules change often. Here is when each type of information was last checked.

Our principles

Verifiable information

We only publish a date, a figure or an adaptation if it comes from a reliable source. When something is not confirmed, we say so, or we leave it out: for example, we do not map seasons to novel chapters without a solid source.

Facts kept apart from opinions

Guides separate information (synopsis, world, release) from the "My review" section, signed by Spidermas, which holds the review and the rating.

Affiliate links disclosed

Some Amazon links are affiliate links: the site earns a small commission on purchases at no extra cost to you. They are always disclosed, and they never influence reviews or ratings.

Quick corrections

Spotted a mistake, a date that has changed, a series that has arrived on a French platform? Write to us and we will fix the guide.

How I rate donghua

Every guide with a review carries a rating by Spidermas, on four criteria scored from 0 to 5 in half points. The overall score is the average of the scored criteria.

Animation
Technical quality and art direction: fluidity, fight choreography, backgrounds, consistency of style from one season to the next.
Story
The story as the series tells it: pacing, characters, tension, quality of the writing.
Faithfulness
Respect for the source work (novel, manhua): plot, characters, tone. This criterion is not scored for original works and free retellings of a myth, such as Ne Zha 2.
Accessibility
How easy it is for a newcomer: length, complexity of the world, need to know the source, availability in France.

Benchmarks: 5 = exceptional, 4 = very good, 3 = decent, 2 = disappointing, 1 = avoid. A rating is reviewed when a new season changes things, and the date of the last update is shown above.

All ratings

TitleAnimationStoryFaithfulnessAccessibilityOverall
Link Click4.55—54.8
Ne Zha 254—4.54.5
Heaven Official's Blessing54.5444.4
A Record of a Mortal's Journey to Immortality4.54.54.53.54.3
Lord of Mysteries4.54.54.53.54.3
Scissor Seven44—54.3
The Legend of Luo Xiaohei54—44.3
To Be Hero X4.54—44.2
White Snake4.53.5—4.54.2
Yao: Chinese Folktales4.54—44.2
Fairies Album4444.54.1
Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation4.54.543.54.1
All Wishes Come True43.5—4.54
Jade Dynasty4.5443.54
Release That Witch44444
Sword of Coming4.54.54.52.54
Renegade Immortal4.54433.9
The King's Avatar3.54443.9
Big Fish & Begonia4.53—43.8
Blades of the Guardians43.543.53.8
Chang'an4.54—33.8
Jiang Ziya4.53—43.8
Ling Cage53.5—33.8
Monkey King: Hero Is Back3.53.5—4.53.8
Spiritpact3.53.53.54.53.8
Tales of Herding Gods4.53.53.53.53.8
The Outcast3.5443.53.8
Fog Hill of Five Elements53—33.7
Battle Through the Heavens43.53.53.53.6
Shrouding the Heavens443.533.6
Slay the Gods43.53.53.53.6
Swallowed Star43.53.53.53.6
The Daily Life of the Immortal King33.53.54.53.6
A Will Eternal3.53.53.53.53.5
Dragon Raja3.53.53.53.53.5
Soul Land3.533.543.5
Spare Me, Great Lord!33.53.543.5
The Demon Hunter433.53.53.5
The Great Ruler433.53.53.5
Throne of Seal3.533.543.5
Dragon Prince Yuan3.533.53.53.4
Martial Peak3.533.53.53.4
Rakshasa Street3.53.53.533.4
Soul Land 2: The Peerless Tang Clan433.533.4
Against the Gods3.533.533.3
Martial Universe333.53.53.3
Perfect World3.53.53.52.53.3
Qin's Moon34—33.3
Stellar Transformations3.5333.53.3
Tales of Demons and Gods33.53.533.3
Wu Geng Ji3.53.5333.3

A mistake, a suggestion?

If you spot inaccurate or outdated information, or if a series has arrived on a French platform, let us know.

Contact us